Monday, March 12, 2012

Springtime in the northwest

As I sit in the Portland, Oregon airport waiting for my flight back to New Orleans, I can look out the window and see rain, overcast skies, and a temperature of 48 degrees. The forecast on TV says more of the same for the next 5 days. No wonder they are so angst-ridden and depressed here.... Oh, well-onward-

The latest Rush Limbaugh flap caught my interest. Seems a Georgetown Law student named Sandra Fluke testified before Congress last week about access to contraception. According to Rush, she stated that she having so much sex that she was going broke paying for contraception, and needed the government to pay for it. He proceeded to mention that we used to refer to women who took money for sex as prostitutes or sluts. The backlash from the public and the media was loud and immediate, prompting Rush to back down and apologize on air a few days later. It was reported that he lost a number of sponsors over the incident.

Let's look a little more closely. It's never appropriate to refer to another person with a malicious slur. But, Rush was (awkwardly) making a valuable point. Ms Fluke was clearly implying that she believes that she has a right to sex without consequences, and that the government has an obligation to pay for that. The problem is, the "government" is us, ALL of us. There are obviously at least a few of us who don't believe contraception is ever appropriate for religious reasons. There is a MUCH larger group of us who accept contraception as useful and appropriate in certain circumstances, but don't believe that the mere existence of effective contraceptives gives anyone a right to use them, much less that society(government ) is obligated to pay for an individuals' use of them.

The reality is that "sex without consequences" does not exist. That's the whole point of Biblical notions of fidelity and marriage. Sex WILL have consequences, even if they are not physical. There ARE moral implications to sex, no matter what. They may be subtle, they may be hidden from the outside, but no individual is unaffected by having sexual intercourse. It alters the ways we look at every other relationship in our lives.

Further, this is just the latest in a seemingly never-ending series of demands for more government intrusion into our lives. When government pays for contraception, it means all of us are paying for contraception, via taxes. Forget the argument that over whether or not health care should be provided by government; this is NOT the same argument. This is clearly an argument over whether an individual should be responsible for their own lifestyle choices or not.

I have no other knowledge of Ms Fluke, and therefore can't really make any statement about her. I do know that are some fundamental truths that she hasn't accepted. I can only pray that someday she will understand why all the monotheistic religions discourage sex outside of marriage. There really is great wisdom in that concept.

No comments:

Post a Comment