Thursday, March 10, 2011

Back where he always belonged

Mardi Gras just ended in New Orleans and that seems to be an appropriate time to end Oldy's absence from blogging. Getting established in a new city has been perhaps more time-consuming than I originally anticipated, so no updates for a while. Anyway, that's my story and I'm sticking to it!
So let's take a look at the news: NPR-CEO Vivian Schiller and Development director Ron Schiller(no relation) resign in the wake of undercover video showing Ron Schiller's deep bias against Conservatives and in particular the Tea Party. He thought he was speaking to a potential muslim benefactor when he described Tea Partier's as being "racist" and Republicans as being "less well-educated" than Democrats.
How sad as well as incredibly hypocritical. I have loved NPR for many years. Their reporting, particularly international, is far and away the most incisive and interesting of the networks. Yet in recent years the liberal bias has become inescapable, even for someone like me who didn't want to believe it existed. I listened to right wing commentators bash NPR, and tried to tell myself it was just jealousy or ignorance talking, until I could no longer deny it. The release of a fine journalist(and admitted proud Liberal) like Juan Williams, basically for not being Liberal enough, was a clue to the problems existing at NPR. This latest incident should be the final nail in the coffin for federal funding of public broadcasting. And while the national offices of NPR are only getting what they deserve, the smaller(especially rural) affiliates will suffer disproportionately as they depend more heavily on federal funding than do bigger urban stations. Hopefully, NPR will emerge from this after a serious reorganization to reclaim the high ground of deep, thoughtful news reporting they were once praised for.

Pro-life/Pro-choice-ok, I'll dive into this never-ending maelstrom again-
I was intrigued by a opinion piece I stumbled over today at a site called Scarleteen, Sex-Ed for the Real World, titled, "I used to be a Pro-Life Republican." A thoughtful piece, authored by an obviously bright young woman, it makes the case for abortion as a necessary function of sex education and public health. She acknowledges that she missed the point of the pro-life debate earlier in her life when she criticized women who would consider abortion as being morally inferior. She comes to realize that she wasn't really arguing against abortion as much as she was reassuring herself of her own self-worth because she was a virgin. She changes her mind in college when she meets a young man who she falls in love with and to whom she loses her virginity.
She deserves credit for realizing and acknowledging her mistakes. The problem is, she still misses the point about abortion. She claims that she never heard about STD prevention, contraception and pap smear screening until she lost her own virginity and went searching for an abortion provider(that she ultimately didn't need). That may be so, and it is a shame that that those services are both needed and not more widely available, but that is not an argument in support of abortions rights. The heart of the question is this: When does a "pregnancy" become a "baby"? Is there some definable, distinct difference between a conceptus and a baby? Some have suggested that fetal viability should be the determinant. But when is that? In my own experience, when I began my career in medicine some 30 years ago, very few babies born at or under 30 weeks gestation could survive. Improvements in neonatal care have pushed this date back to 24 weeks and maybe less. Was a 28 week old baby in the womb in 2011 NOT a baby(and therefore eligible to be aborted) in 1981? When did that change, and who decided?
The conflict is this: Either you believe a conception is a baby, and that abortion is therefore a murder(and that the baby deserves the same protections from being murdered that we all have) or you don't. If a conception isn't a baby from day 1, when does it become a baby? This is the unanswerable question, and the fault in all pro-abortion arguments. STD education, contraception and pap smear screening are all separate, albeit related issues. One can be in favor of expanded access to education in the risks/responsibilities of sexual activity(as i am) and be pro-life. I hope someday this young woman will see and understand.

Happy Lenten Season to all-that's it for Oldy this time.