Sunday, December 29, 2013

Another take on Bigfoot and College Football

I know, I know, I said last time that the next post would be on the Affordable Care Act, or "Obamacare." Well, sorry.  It's my blog, I get to change my mind.

First, the bowls-

Part A) Louisiana-Lafayette beat Tulane 24-21 in the New Orleans Bowl on December 21, 2013.  It was a very good game, that went down to the last play.  Both teams deserve congratulations on fine seasons.  Moreover, this year's New Orleans Bowl set a record for attendance with around 55,000.  Ironic fact: The 2013 New Orleans Bowl had more people in attendance than the last 2 Sugar Bowls, which were played in the same stadium. (the Superdome)  The New Orleans Bowl is likely to have the highest attendance of the non-BCS bowls.   It might even sneak past a BCS bowl.  So, there, BCS!

Part B)  Yesterday, I watched parts of the New Era Pinstripe Bowl from Yankee Stadium in NY in which Notre Dame beat Rutgers, and the Buffalo Wild Wings Bowl from Tempe, Arizona, featuring Kansas State defeated Michigan.  Neither was well attended.  Michigan finishes the season 7-6, and Rutgers managed a glittering 6-7 record.....

What's the point? I know, someone is making money from the 30-35 bowl games played every year.  But wouldn't they make a lot more money from a real playoff, similar to Men's basketball?  Of course they would.  The problem is that the existing powers in college football (the current Automatic Qualifying Conferences, and ESPN) would lose some of their influence and, just maybe, profits if that happened.  That's because while the profit would grow significantly, it would also be distributed more widely.  Just like in men's basketball, an occasional Cinderella team would sneak in and win big, thereby sharing the pot with the big programs. And that just can't be tolerated.  The worst offender of the existing power-brokers, the Southeastern Conference, would fight (and has fought) the hardest against a real playoff.   The collective ego of the SEC is simply too large to tolerate such a thing.  They perceive that a football playoff would bring national exposure to more programs, which might then make inroads on "their" traditional recruiting areas.  Talented players would start going to the smaller programs, because they'd have a chance to play right away AND a realistic chance to win a championship.  And that's why we won't have a real, equitable playoff system anytime soon.  But we will continue to see Pinstripe Bowls featuring teams with 6-6 records!

Bigfoot-

I'm sure some of you are tired of hearing my thoughts on Bigfoot.  But, there were a couple of major newsmakers this year that caused me to think about the big guy again-the Falcon Project, and the Ketchum Bigfoot DNA Analysis.

The Falcon Project was/is an innovative idea: put a drone with a camera up over likely target areas for days or weeks at a time-far more time (and area) than any ground-locked human searcher could cover.  If Bigfoot exists, it must do so in very small numbers, no more than a few thousand scattered over a number of widely separated areas in the U.S. and Canada in terrain that is very inhospitable to humans, making it extremely unlikely that even a dedicated researcher would encounter a Bigfoot-or so the argument goes.  The Falcon Project drone could search vastly larger areas for much longer time periods, perhaps even "tagging"a live specimen by dropping a transmitter-equipped banana that would be eaten.  A Bigfoot tagged in such a manner might even lead investigators to other specimens, providing conclusive evidence once and for all.

The problem is money.  The cost of the project is an estimated $400,000/year.  The sponsors have thus far generated only a small fraction of that amount.  Fundraisers, including a Kickstarter campaign have been disappointing.  Why? Probably because the majority of the scientific community either ignores or openly disapproves of Bigfoot research.  Plus, at least some of the pro-Bigfoot community oppose Falcon because they see Bigfoot not as an animal to be tagged, but some kind of proto-human who deserves privacy.  They find the idea of inserting something into Bigfoot akin to Nazi-era experimentation, and vehemently reject it.  Oh, well.....

The Ketchum DNA analysis also grabbed lots of mainstream media headlines this year.  The backstory is that Melba Ketchum is a veterinarian who graduated from Texas A&M, but did not complete a PhD. She owns a seemingly respectable commercial forensic DNA analysis lab in Texas.  It typically handles criminal and paternity questions, but was not academic in any sense.  In 2011, a press release from Ketchum made the startling claim that DNA from samples purported to be Bigfoot showed a combination of human and animal sequences and uniquely represented a species hitherto unknown to science.  The press release promised a follow up paper in a reputable academic journal.

It turned out not to be.  There was no paper anywhere in the world literature until February of 2013, when a journal titled De Novo: Journal of Science, published it's premiere issue, featuring one single paper, titled, "Novel North American Homi­­­nins, Next Generation Sequencing of Three Whole Genomes and Associated Studies", of which Melba Ketchum was first author.  It was quickly discovered that Melba Ketchum actually owned the journal De Novo, raising huge conflict of interest issues which she has never addressed.  Further, while the actual techniques used were more or less legitimate, multiple reviewers denounced the manuscript as a whole, citing numerous flaws in the data collection and validation process.  There were even multiple grammatical and typographical errors in the published product.  The whole thing has since been dismissed by the scientific community and virtually all of the Bigfoot community.   Oh, well, again.......

What are we to make of these episodes?  Primarily, that widespread scientific evidence will be extremely difficult to come by.  So many Bigfoot claims have been either overtly fraudulent or at least ethically questionable that most legitimate scientific investigators are afraid to touch the subject, which is understandable.    

And what is the truth?  I think we still don't know, and am trying to keep an open mind.  Could there be an unknown animal species of some size in North America? Undoubtedly.  Several such species have been found in recent years.  It would require a current population of around 5000 animals, given that they seem to be scattered in several disparate areas, including the Pacific Northwest, Texas-Arkansas-La border area, Ohio/Pennsylvania/midwest, and a few other smaller spots.  They would have to be omnivorous, and possess significant intelligence, something like the great apes.  They must have evolutionary plausibility, such as the Gigantopithecus Blacki theory, which states that fossilized bony specimens found in Asia could have come from a 10 foot tall ape-like creature that could have crossed the Bering Straight land bridge along with humans into North America and whose descendants are now known as Bigfoot.   

If nothing else, it's fun to believe (at least, it is to Oldy) that there could be unknown things out there.  Happy new Year!