Saturday, December 31, 2011

Happy New Year to all! It's your blogger's hope that everyone has had a wonderful Holiday season and will have a fulfilling 2012. It's been a pretty good year for Oldy and family, certainly better than 2010, so that's something for which to be thankful.

On to current events: The Republican Presidential Nominating Process-like many others, Oldy is struggling to figure out what to make of this. Most of the candidates are good, solid people with reasonable political philosophies. Yet none are terribly inspiring. With the Iowa Caucus just a few days away, let's take a individual look at the choices:

Mitt Romney-still seems to be the front runner, but has yet to catch fire. His poll numbers have hovered in the 20-25% range for the entire campaign. Mitt seems to be a good man, with executive experience as MA Governor, and certainly would be a terrific improvement over Barack Obama. But he has an unnerving history of accommodating political opponents and switching positions for expedience' sake. Conservatives simply can't find it within themselves to go "all in" for him. Hence the timid support.

Newt Gingrich-the brilliant former Speaker of the House during the most prolific Republican ascendancy in that body in a century. Far and away the most sophisticated conservative thinker in the race, and the current main challenger to Romney in the polls. However, Newt has created many enemies over his long career and left others questioning his leadership style and ability. Add to that his significant ethical baggage and you've got a tarnished candidate. The Speaker has in recent years professed a renewal in his Christian faith that seems sincere. And, as the leader of that faith said, we should forgive others not just seven, but seventy times seven transgressions. Still....

Rick Perry-the Texas Governor entered the race like a house afire-being portrayed by the media as an immediate front-runner. Unfortunately, that blaze fizzled rapidly amidst a number of embarrassing gaffes in the debates and elsewhere. Who will ever forget Perry bringing up the notion that he would eliminate 3 federal agencies, and then only being able to remember 2? Do you want him matching wits with the Chinese, Russians or anybody else?

Michele Bachmann-a Tea Party favorite and rigid conservative-rigid to the point of seeming extreme. How can an intelligent argument be made against the cervical cancer vaccine? It can't be done without looking silly, yet Rep. Bachmann keeps trying over and over again.....

Rick Santorum-another Tea Party-acceptable candidate. Similar to Bachmann, Santorum seems to think social issues are the nation's primary concern. Someone send him Bill Clinton's famous memo; "It's the economy, stupid."

Ron Paul-He's like your funny uncle that you'd prefer to keep out of sight most of the time. For all his good sense on economic issues, he just seems dangerous in his passion for isolationism. The world is simply too interconnected for America to ignore anymore. The latest evidence of his separation from reality is the claim that a nuclear Iran would be of no particular consequence to the U.S. The Iranian leadership has promised to wipe Israel off the map. It seems likely that the Israelis would pre-emptively attack an Iran on the verge of having nuclear weapons. World War III, anyone? And the U.S. could sit it out?

So, Oldy's choice? Originally it was Gingrich, and still is, but with some misgivings. It seems we'll have to wait for events to unfold. That's all for now-see you in 2012!

Sunday, October 16, 2011

What a good time to blog! So many fascinating things going on in the U.S. and the world. Once again, here's Oldy's take on a few of them:

1) Tulane Football(start with the less-serious stuff)-All is woe for the Tulane Football fan. The beloved(but mostly ignored) Green Wave lost yesterday, 44-7 to the unintimidating UTEP. The Wave was actually favored by one going into this game, and proceeded to lay a massive egg. The Greenies were sloppy, yielding multiple interceptions, blocked punts, and sacks. This comes on the heels of a series of embarrassing losses(Army, Duke, Syracuse) that featured multiple coaching decisions perceived as bad by the dwindling fanbase.

Unfortunately, Head Coach Bob Toledo was already on a very short leash this season, having never guided his team to more than 4 wins in a season over a 5 year tenure. Worse, the attendance in the stands has dropped to an alltime low: there were no more than 2000 actual bodies in the Superdome for the game. Local media outlets have all but stopped coverage of the team because of the perceived lack of interest.

It seems likely that Tulane will have a new Head Coach, perhaps as early as this week, certainly by the end of the season. Former Tulane assistant and Michigan Head Coach Rich Rodriguez has emerged as the favorite of the few remaining(but very vocal) fans. Coach Rod served as Offensive Coordinator under Tommy Bowden during Tulane's brief glory era, when the team went 12-0 and finished seventh in the nation in 1998. Your blogger met and had multiple discussions with Rich in that era, and came away impressed with his knowledge of football and his character. He would be a very solid choice.

2) Th "Occupy" phenomena- what started as a small protest of capitalism at the foot of Wall Street in NY, has sprung up in multiple areas around the country. Groups of mostly youthful, unkempt protestors have been quoted as opposing everything from corporate greed to bathing.
This movement calls to mind the protests of the 1960's among those old enough to remember. Similar frustrations with the status quo and anti-establishment feelings were expressed. The difference is the lack of focus, which greatly detracts from the public's willingness to take the current activists seriously. The protests of the 1960's were based largely on 2 things: civil rights and the war in Vietnam. In contrast, today's protests are non-focused and often non-sensical. The participants have been quoted as protesting "Wall Street" or "corporations" in general, with no real insight as to what it is about these essential, indeed indispensable parts of the American economy that they don't like. Further, the extreme filth of the physical site, coupled with media reports of public defecation and sexual activity among the protestors have served to alienate virtually all of the audience which they are trying to persuade.

There is certainly room for frustration in America. Jobs are scarce; money is tight, and selling a home is almost impossible. However, these problems are not a function of the capitalist system as much as they are a result of the manipulation of that system by misguided politicians. The Obama administration has created a level of financial uncertainty that hasn't been seen since the Great Depression. As a result, banks are very reluctant to lend money, and employers are unwilling to take the risks required to expand their businesses and create new jobs.

The massive Federal deficit, with no apparent end in sight due to ever-rising spending favored by President Obama, combined with the nationalization of the Healthcare system, which affects perhaps 20% of the national economy, have combined (along with several other items) to strangle any economic recovery. Many media observers (usually of leftist political persuasion) have urged a "Great Compromise," combining spending cuts with increased taxes in order to cut the deficit. To date, the Republicans, often led by so-called "Tea Party" activists, have been unwilling to accept any new taxes. Critics of this intransigence fail to realize that the political right perceives that it has in fact BEEN compromising it's small-government, low-tax principles for decades and this is where it's gotten them. Their feeling is that it's time for the left to compromise, since it's been proven over and over again that income redistribution never works, and only results in a smaller total economic pie.

As I've suggested before, it increasingly appears that we are headed toward two distinct Americas, with entirely different and unreconcilable political philosophies. The result the last time this occurred was the American Civil War. The differences in that conflict and the current situation are largely in the underlying ethics of the opposing positions. The Confederate cause, based as it was on the defense of human slavery, was indefensible on any level. In contrast, the positions of the two sides today are much less black and white, at least on a purely ethical basis. Perhaps we would be better off with two separate countries if we get along with each other so poorly anymore. Let's hope not, but that if it comes to be, we would have the sense to let it end in a national version of a no-fault divorce, allowing both sides to shake hands and walk away, rather than an all out military conflict, as happened before.

Now you've heard Oldy's take-Thanks for listening!

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Good Old Summertime

Summer in New Orleans is hot and humid as always. The last few days have finally seen a return of typical summer weather here: a late afternoon thunderstorm that moves off quickly, with heat and humidity the rest of the day. Prior to a week ago, we'd had a VERY dry spring/summer, so the rain is needed.

So, onto other things- we are threatened once again with a government shut down-this time as a result of the federal debt ceiling, which is quickly being approached. The Republicans are demanding spending cuts before they will agree to raise the ceiling, and the Democrats are demanding tax increases AND an immediate increase in the ceiling. What to make of it all?

Well, federal spending has increased astronomically under the Obama administration. The President clearly believes in redistribution of the nation's wealth, and is trying his best to force it on us all. In contrast, the Republicans are more determined than ever to fight back, having been emboldened by the results of the 2010 elections, which revealed a strong negative reaction in the country to the President's first 2 years in office. The rise of the Tea Party movement has pushed the Republicans to take a more forceful stand against big government than ever.

The result is a nation as polarized as it's been in many years, at least since the Vietnam era protests, perhaps longer. And, if anything, the issues at the heart of the current debate are even more fundamental to American life. This is truly a question of what we as a people want our government to be. And unfortunately, there seems to be a growing separation between the two sides. Further, that separation is becoming geographic as well as psychologic. The pro-big government forces are strongest on the coasts and the inner cities. The supporters of limited government are in control in most of the old Confederacy, the mid- and mountain west and the suburbs.

I wonder a little more each day if this nation WILL be able to reconcile these conflicting beliefs. It's one thing to agree to disagree, but it's another to agree to disagree about what is arguably the most fundamental understanding of our government. Can the nation continue to exist as a whole with such disparate views among its' citizens? Perhaps a better question would be, should the nation continue to exist with such levels of dysfunction? If this were family court, and the husband and wife were this polarized, it's likely that a divorce would be strongly considered. Is that where we're going? Is that where we should be going? Is this such a taboo that we are afraid even to ask the question? Would we be more functional by separating into something like a United Socialist States of America, representing the Left; and a Republic of the United States, representing Conservatives? I'm not close to being ready to answer that question personally, but I am getting closer to being willing to ask it.

Sunday, April 3, 2011

Hello all! It's been a very pleasant Spring in New Orleans so far-reminds me of why I like it here so much. I guess I've never really been a fan of Winter, so I don't miss it. We set a couple of palm trees out in the back yard last week....

Anyway, the latest issue on the international scene is occurring in Libya, where rebels have seized most of the eastern half of the country from the forces of long-time dictator Moammar Qaddafi.(sp?) And just when it appeared that the poorly armed and organized rebels were about to be overrun and/or slaughtered by the regular army,(which has remained remarkably loyal to Qaddafi) a group of western nations, led by the U.S., intervened with air strikes and Tomahawk missile firings. Qaddafi's forces were pushed back but not eradicated. They appear to have stabilized the situation, retaining firm control of the capitol, Tripoli. Meanwhile, the rebel forces seem to be incapable of finishing what they started by pushing the loyalists out. The strategic situation currently appears to be approaching stalemate.

So what was/is the strategic goal of the U.S. in this situation? America has long opposed Qaddafi's government, but has never made an overt attempt to drive him out of power. President Obama has suggested that the purpose was to prevent Qaddafi from slaughtering his own people. A noble goal, perhaps, but similar situations in other regions have not prompted U.S. intervention. So what is different about Libya?

The answer is unclear to me, and it seems just as unclear to the Obama administration, based on their statements during the crisis. For the Europeans, the motivation may be stabilization of their oil supplies(several European nations are dependent on Libyan oil). But that's not the situation with the U.S. Obviously, the oil market is global, so a ripple in one area affects the entire market, but the U.S. gets essentially no oil directly from Libya. So why are we there?

And, who is calling the shots at the White House? This action seems contrary to Obama's personal philosophy on U.S. military power. He has emphatically been a non-interventionist throughout his(admittedly brief) national political career. Could this action be a manifestation of Secy of State Hillary Clinton's influence? It seems more in character with her political philosophy. Even so, the direct benefit to the U.S. is illusory. We perhaps prevented an immediate slaughter, but there are many opportunities to do that in an increasingly violent world. We may also have simply delayed the slaughter, or drawn it out over a prolonged period of time. No one from the administration(or anywhere else) has articulated a realistic policy that can bring this military action to a swift and satisfactory conclusion. There is no scheme to remove Qaddafi from office, which most observers agree is a necessary component of any successful strategy. Where do we go from here, Mr President?

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Back where he always belonged

Mardi Gras just ended in New Orleans and that seems to be an appropriate time to end Oldy's absence from blogging. Getting established in a new city has been perhaps more time-consuming than I originally anticipated, so no updates for a while. Anyway, that's my story and I'm sticking to it!
So let's take a look at the news: NPR-CEO Vivian Schiller and Development director Ron Schiller(no relation) resign in the wake of undercover video showing Ron Schiller's deep bias against Conservatives and in particular the Tea Party. He thought he was speaking to a potential muslim benefactor when he described Tea Partier's as being "racist" and Republicans as being "less well-educated" than Democrats.
How sad as well as incredibly hypocritical. I have loved NPR for many years. Their reporting, particularly international, is far and away the most incisive and interesting of the networks. Yet in recent years the liberal bias has become inescapable, even for someone like me who didn't want to believe it existed. I listened to right wing commentators bash NPR, and tried to tell myself it was just jealousy or ignorance talking, until I could no longer deny it. The release of a fine journalist(and admitted proud Liberal) like Juan Williams, basically for not being Liberal enough, was a clue to the problems existing at NPR. This latest incident should be the final nail in the coffin for federal funding of public broadcasting. And while the national offices of NPR are only getting what they deserve, the smaller(especially rural) affiliates will suffer disproportionately as they depend more heavily on federal funding than do bigger urban stations. Hopefully, NPR will emerge from this after a serious reorganization to reclaim the high ground of deep, thoughtful news reporting they were once praised for.

Pro-life/Pro-choice-ok, I'll dive into this never-ending maelstrom again-
I was intrigued by a opinion piece I stumbled over today at a site called Scarleteen, Sex-Ed for the Real World, titled, "I used to be a Pro-Life Republican." A thoughtful piece, authored by an obviously bright young woman, it makes the case for abortion as a necessary function of sex education and public health. She acknowledges that she missed the point of the pro-life debate earlier in her life when she criticized women who would consider abortion as being morally inferior. She comes to realize that she wasn't really arguing against abortion as much as she was reassuring herself of her own self-worth because she was a virgin. She changes her mind in college when she meets a young man who she falls in love with and to whom she loses her virginity.
She deserves credit for realizing and acknowledging her mistakes. The problem is, she still misses the point about abortion. She claims that she never heard about STD prevention, contraception and pap smear screening until she lost her own virginity and went searching for an abortion provider(that she ultimately didn't need). That may be so, and it is a shame that that those services are both needed and not more widely available, but that is not an argument in support of abortions rights. The heart of the question is this: When does a "pregnancy" become a "baby"? Is there some definable, distinct difference between a conceptus and a baby? Some have suggested that fetal viability should be the determinant. But when is that? In my own experience, when I began my career in medicine some 30 years ago, very few babies born at or under 30 weeks gestation could survive. Improvements in neonatal care have pushed this date back to 24 weeks and maybe less. Was a 28 week old baby in the womb in 2011 NOT a baby(and therefore eligible to be aborted) in 1981? When did that change, and who decided?
The conflict is this: Either you believe a conception is a baby, and that abortion is therefore a murder(and that the baby deserves the same protections from being murdered that we all have) or you don't. If a conception isn't a baby from day 1, when does it become a baby? This is the unanswerable question, and the fault in all pro-abortion arguments. STD education, contraception and pap smear screening are all separate, albeit related issues. One can be in favor of expanded access to education in the risks/responsibilities of sexual activity(as i am) and be pro-life. I hope someday this young woman will see and understand.

Happy Lenten Season to all-that's it for Oldy this time.