It's been quite the season so far for long-suffering Tulane fans. The Green Wave are a surprising (and bowl-eligible) 6-4 going into the final 2 games of the regular season. It's been 11 long years since the team has won this many games, and the fans are excited. At this point, the New Orleans Bowl seems to be the most likely destination for the Wave. Congratulation to Coach Johnson, his assistants and the team on a job well done. Next year, we'll have a new on-campus stadium, a more mature group of players(the team is currently dominated by sophomores and freshman), but a tougher schedule. Oldy will be there to bring you updates, as always.
Oldy read a couple of op-ed pieces today that got him thinking about the idea of collective guilt. The first was a New York Times piece on the inability/unwillingness of Dallas to live up to it's presumed responsibility for the assassination of JFK in 1963, and the other was a admission by a New Orleans Times-Picayune writer of family shame for a great grandfather who had owned slaves in Pre-Civil War Louisiana. I admit to not being able to identify with either of these concerns. In the first, the author recounted that his grandparents had been wealthy Dallas residents in 1963, and like many of the neighbors, were very conservative and very opposed politically to John Kennedy. To begin with, ascribing the guilt of one evil man to a class of people is a classic liberal ploy to win converts. I'd be willing to bet the author's grandparents were horrified, as were most other Texans, at the news of the assassination. His politics made no difference. In fact, many of those same people disliked Lyndon Johnson's political philosophy at least as much, and had no desire to see him become President. The bottom line was that in 1963, America was relatively naive about the vulnerability of a President and was not protecting him in the numerous ways we now do. Lee Harvey Oswald(and whoever he worked with-if you believe that) could have gotten Kennedy at almost any other U.S. city in that era using the exact same techniques. It was the nature of the times. Ascribing guilt to the city of Dallas as a whole, much less continuing to do so 50 years later, is ludicrous.
The second piece was a reaction to the recent film, "12 Years a Slave," a fascinating story of a free black man from the northern U.S. who was kidnapped into slavery and taken to Louisiana in1842, where he remained until 1854. (Admission: I read the book but did not see the movie) The Louisiana writer bemoans the fact that his great grandfather was a slave owner, and just can't imagine what he was thinking. The author clearly feels hereditary guilt, and just as clearly wants all white southerners to wallow in the same emotional malaise he claims he does. He ignores the fact that it's been 150 years years since slavery ended. More importantly, he ignores the fact that all of us have relatives whose actions were occasionally less than honorable. Some were horrendous. Do we ask ourselves to feel guilty about that? Would we insist that the children/grandchildren of mobsters bare the blame for their parent's crimes-or be responsible for repaying the victims, as this article suggests should occur in regards to slavery? Further, do we blame children whose fathers participated in some activity that was not even recognized as a crime at the time? By that example, the children of whisky distillers would have been criminals during prohibition.
The American Founders created an imperfect system, and the biggest imperfection was clearly tolerance of slavery. But that system is still better than any other created before or since. More importantly, we found a way as a nation to correct that imperfection-a very painful way, requiring a bloody Civil War, but the system worked. It still and will always have imperfections, just as anything created by man does. In fact, there are probably quirks of the system right now that will be viewed in the future as a problem, but we as a nation will likely continue to try to correct them.
Bottom line is that attempts to spread collective guilt, particularly over events that occurred before anyone living was old enough to do anything about it, is an pathetic attempt to shame people into agreeing with a political position, pure and simple. It is NOT an ethical or moral issue. Judeo-Christian ethics do not blame a child for the sins of the father, but instead offers redemption for all. Modern liberal writers generally have little use for Judeo-Christian thought anyway, so I'm not surprised that they don't know(or choose not to acknowledge) this fact.
Next time: Health care and the Affordable Care Act. See ya!
Sunday, November 17, 2013
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)